All-American Awards

NCAA Division III Coach of the Year Finalist

1994 – Sonny Travis
1991 – Sonny Travis
1990 – Sonny Travis

KAPPA National Coach of the Year

1997 – Sonny Travis

NCAA Division III Player of the Year

1992 – Mike McFarland

United Soccer Coaches All-Americans (formerly NSCAA)

2024 - Alex Moody (4th)
2021 – Griffin Potter (3rd)
2003 – Kelvin Murray (2nd)
2002 – Kelvin Murray (2nd)
1997 – Gary DePalma (3rd)
1995 – Gary DePalma (1st), Scott Morgenroth (2nd), Evan Whitson (2nd)
1994 – Mike Duffy (1st)
1992 – Mike McFarland (1st)
1991 – Mike McFarland (1st)
1990 – Mike McFarland (1st), Mike Benne (3rd)
1988 – Alex Kee (3rd)
1983 – Greg Plummer (2nd)

D3kicks.com All-Americans

2007 – Brandon Massie (3rd)